Skip to main content
Back to search resultsResolution 130027

Calling on the City Council of Philadelphia to support, advocate, and recommend a Moratorium (Suspension of Action) for the School District of Philadelphia's Facilities Master Plan recommendations concerning grade changes, school closures, program co-locations, and program mergers/relocations.

View file history View official file on Legistar →

File details

Status
Adopted
Type
Resolution
Introduced
January 24, 2013
Sponsors
CBCouncilmember BlackwellCBCouncilmember BlackwellCindy BassCindy BassCurtis Jones, Jr.Curtis Jones, Jr.CGCouncilmember GoodeCGCouncilmember GoodeCKCouncilmember KenneyCKCouncilmember KenneyCGCouncilmember GreenleeCGCouncilmember GreenleeKenyatta JohnsonKenyatta JohnsonCRCouncilmember Reynolds BrownCRCouncilmember Reynolds BrownCPCouncil President ClarkeCPCouncil President ClarkeCHCouncilmember HenonCHCouncilmember HenonMark SquillaMark SquillaBrian J. O'Neill

Full Bill

WHEREAS, We have come to know over time that, “Human history becomes more and more a race between education and catastrophe” (Wells, H.G.,

The Outline of History

, Ch. 40, 1951); and

WHEREAS, In order to avoid catastrophe, promote progress, and ensure that each student in the City of Philadelphia be afforded an equal, zenithal educational opportunity, a temporary - yet sufficient - delay should be imposed upon the aforementioned School District of Philadelphia Facilities Master Plan recommendations so as to afford all citizens the opportunity to have their voices heard; and

WHEREAS, The School District of Philadelphia will require ample time to incorporate said considerations when, where, and if possible, into their final plan; and

WHEREAS, While a temporary suspension of action is recommended, it is understood that the School District of Philadelphia faces a significant budget crisis which, in order to address said financial shortfall, requires a myriad of efforts, including the closing of some schools; and

WHEREAS, The School District of Philadelphia has provided to the public the criteria for their recommendations which include, but are not limited to, building quality (measured by the district's Facilities Condition Index), academic performance (measured by a school's Adequate Yearly Progress), utilization (measured by a school's student enrollment divided by its respective building capacity), and cost (measured by cost per student); and

WHEREAS, A suspension of action may prove futile if specific steps are not proposed and agreed upon as to what the School District of Philadelphia can do to obtain additional revenue, if issues relating to the negative social and economic impact school closures will have on already impoverished neighborhoods are not addressed, and if data from studies of previous efforts to close schools on a similar scale in cities across the country that contradict the district's claims of substantial financial gain and increased academic achievement are overlooked; now therefore, be it,

Resolved, That the City Council of Philadelphia, Shall support, advocate, and recommend a Moratorium (Suspension of Action) for the School District of Philadelphia's Facilities Master Plan recommendations concerning grade changes, school closures, program co-locations, and program mergers/relocations.

End

Timeline

File history

A file can move through several public steps, including introduction, hearings, amendments, votes and final action. This timeline puts those events in date order, groups routine entries from the same day, and attaches published member votes to the action they record.

  1. Member voteCITY COUNCIL

    ADOPTED

    Member-by-member vote published for this action.

    Pass14 Yes · 2 No · 1 AbsentView member votes →
    Official action detail

    A motion was made that this matter be ADOPTED. The motion carried by the following vote:

    Member votes

    MemberVote
    Bill GreenNo
    Blondell Reynolds BrownYes
    Bobby HenonYes
    Brian J. O'NeillYes
    Cindy BassYes
    Curtis Jones, Jr.Yes
    Darrell L. ClarkeYes
    David OhYes
    Dennis M. O'BrienYes
    James F. KenneyAbsent
    Jannie L. BlackwellYes
    Kenyatta JohnsonYes
    Maria D. Quiñones-SánchezNo
    Marian B. TascoYes
    Mark SquillaYes
    W. Wilson Goode, Jr.Yes
    William K. GreenleeYes

    Source: LegislationDetail.aspx · gridLegislation

    UnanimousCITY COUNCIL

    Introduced and Ordered Placed on This Week's Final Passage Calendar

    Marked unanimous; no member-by-member tally published.

    Pass
    Official action detail

    A motion was made by Councilmember Blackwell that this matter be Introduced and Ordered Placed on This Week's Final Passage Calendar. The motion carried unanimously.

    Source: LegislationDetail.aspx · gridLegislation