Skip to main content
Back to search resultsBill 140017

Amending Chapter 20-304, of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "Compensation for Members of Boards, Commissions, Committees and Councils," by repealing Bill No. 100212, thereby returning the compensation for members of the Board of Revision of Taxes to the level existing prior to the passage of that bill; all under certain terms and conditions.

AI summary

The enacted bill repealed Bill No. 100212 and restored compensation for members of Philadelphia’s Board of Revision of Taxes to the level in effect before April 22, 2010. It affects the compensation of members serving on that board.

File details

Status
ENACTED
Introduced
January 23, 2014
Sponsors
Mark SquillaJFJames F. KenneyBobby Henon
View official record ↗

Full text

WHEREAS, Bill No. 100212, which was enacted into law on April 22, 2010, was intended to substantially decrease the compensation for all members of the Board of Revision of Taxes; and

WHEREAS, City Council voted to enact Bill No. 100212 based on the assumption that members of the Board of Revision of Taxes were not public officials under the Pennsylvania Constitution, and that their salaries would be reduced immediately upon passage of legislation; and

WHEREAS, Bill No. 100212 was passed in reliance on the laws that existed on April 22, 2010, that would have abolished the Board of Revision of Taxes and eliminated all duties of the members of the Board as of October 1, 2010; and

WHEREAS, After the enactment of Bill No. 100212, the Pennsylvania Courts found the ordinance, approved by the voters of Philadelphia, that purported to abolish the Board of Revision of Taxes to be unconstitutional in part, so that the Board remains in existence to date, fulfilling its appellate responsibilities; and

WHEREAS, The Pennsylvania Courts subsequently held that Bill No. 100212 was also unconstitutional if applied as intended, and therefore, the compensation of the sitting members of the Board was not immediately reduced as intended; and

WHEREAS, It was never the intent of Bill No. 100212 to apply the compensation reductions solely to future terms of members of the Board of Revision of Taxes; now, therefore

THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PHILADELPHIA HEREBY ORDAINS:

SECTION 1. In reliance on the Commonwealth Court decision, issued on March 20, 2013, (

Meade, et al v. City of Philadelphia

, 65 A.3d 1031), affirming the ruling of the Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas decision that provisions in Bill No. 100212 violated the Pennsylvania Constitution, Article III, § 27, by attempting to reduce the compensation of members of the Board of Revision of Taxes during their term of office, Council hereby amends Section 20-304(7) of The Philadelphia Code by repealing and abrogating Bill No. 100212, and reverting to the compensation as set forth in Section 20-304(7) immediately preceding April 22, 2010.

End

File history

Sometimes city council's record keeping is not complete. This timeline reflects the information on the council's legistar website.
  1. Council actionMAYOR

    No action taken

  2. Council actionCITY COUNCIL

    Ordered placed on next week`s second reading calendar

    Council actionCITY COUNCIL

    Suspend the rules of the council

    Pass
    Council actionCITY COUNCIL

    Ordered placed on this day`s first reading calendar

  3. Council actionCommittee on Appropriations

    Reported favorably, rule suspension requested

    Council actionCommittee on Appropriations

    Amended

    Council actionCommittee on Appropriations

    Hearing held

    Council actionCommittee on Appropriations

    Hearing notices sent

  4. Council actionCommittee of the Whole

    Cancellation of Scheduled Public Hearing

    Council actionCommittee of the Whole

    Hearing notices sent

  5. Council actionCITY COUNCIL

    Re-Referred

  6. Council actionCITY COUNCIL

    Introduced and Referred

    Pass