Skip to main content
Back to search resultsCOMMUNICATION 140505

May 22, 2014 TO THE PRESIDENT AND MEMBERS OF THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PHILADELPHIA: For the reasons set forth below, I hereby return unsigned to your Honorable Body Bill No. 140093, which passed Council on May 8, 2014. This Bill would amend the Fire Code to declare that Fire Service Paramedics must be considered firemen for the purposes of the Act of June 28, 1935, referred to as the Enforcement Officer Disability Benefits Law, or the Heart and Lung Act. As my Administration has testified, and as the Law Department has advised, the question of whether Fire Service Paramedics are firemen for purposes of the Heart and Lung Act is a question of state law that must be decided by the courts or the General Assembly. I honor the important and heroic work of Fire Service Paramedics. However, it is simply not possible to change state law through City legislation in this way. Accordingly, I am constrained to return this Bill w...

AI summary

This communication reports that Mayor Michael Nutter returned unsigned Bill No. 140093, which would have amended the Fire Code to treat Fire Service Paramedics as firemen under Pennsylvania’s Heart and Lung Act for disability benefits. The communication states that whether paramedics qualify under that state law must be decided by the courts or the General Assembly; the item was placed on file.

File details

Status
PLACED ON FILE
Introduced
May 22, 2014
View official record ↗

Full text

Title

May 22, 2014

TO THE PRESIDENT AND MEMBERS OF THE

COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PHILADELPHIA:

For the reasons set forth below, I hereby return unsigned to your Honorable Body Bill No. 140093, which passed Council on May 8, 2014.

This Bill would amend the Fire Code to declare that Fire Service Paramedics must be considered firemen for the purposes of the Act of June 28, 1935, referred to as the Enforcement Officer Disability Benefits Law, or the Heart and Lung Act.

As my Administration has testified, and as the Law Department has advised, the question of whether Fire Service Paramedics are firemen for purposes of the Heart and Lung Act is a question of state law that must be decided by the courts or the General Assembly.

I honor the important and heroic work of Fire Service Paramedics. However, it is simply not possible to change state law through City legislation in this way. Accordingly, I am constrained to return this Bill without my signature.

Respectfully,

MICHAEL A. NUTTER

End

File history

Sometimes city council's record keeping is not complete. This timeline reflects the information on the council's legistar website.
  1. Council actionCITY COUNCIL

    Read